Of what value, at what cost?

In any review of the government’s budget for national defence, a sharp focus should be placed on the Snowbirds, the aerobatic flying team. Questions need to be asked about the value of this demonstration flying group to the people of Canada.

Although many Canadians have seen the Snowbirds in flight, it is only for a few fleeting moments. Does this really generate some sense of pride? What other reasons might there be to continue with a national “spectacle” that has resulted in 5 deaths since 1972, with the destruction of numerous aircraft. Questions need to be asked about the total costs to maintain the squadron. Many aircraft are required with ongoing maintenance and operational costs. Salaries and benefits for supporting officers at headquarters, supervisors, ground and flight crew and the future costs relating to pensions, all contribute to high final costs. Most thinking Canadians would look at all the costs in relationship to the values that are actually derived. The monies that would be saved by disbanding the squadron could be used for other programs that might assist the poor, the homeless, the hungry and the unemployed. There are many programs that affect the people that could use additional funding.

A review of the Snowbirds schedule for 2005 indicates 60 days of participation in events; 40 days in Canada and 20 days in the United States. Of the 40 days in Canada, 16 days are in the province of Ontario, 14 of which are in southern Ontario. Is this a national program in which all Canadians can take pride, whatever that might mean?

How many Canadians know anything about Millville, New Jersey or Millington, Tennessee? Hardly any! Yet four days will be spent at those two locations. Why? Will there be any value gained for Canadians, including Canadian pride?

How many Canadians know anything about Nunavut, the North West Territories, New Brunswick, Prince Edward Island, Newfoundland and Labrador? Very many! Yet, no days will be spent in any of those locations. What is the value or importance of the Snowbirds to the residents of those areas?

The Government of Canada should disband the squadron; give Canadians a break by reducing taxes and by increasing benefits for Canadians who have significant needs!